I’m eyeing these mascaras… Help me decide!

I wear mascara every day, even if I’m just hanging around the house. (And in this case the only other “makeup” I’ll use is Natura Bissé’s tinted Diamond Cocoon Sheer Eye.) For me, it’s also imperative to have mascara options for casual days and dressier occasions, and it just so happens I’m running low on my Saie Mascara 101 and MERIT Beauty Clean Lash. This means the hunt is on for replacements, and these are at the top of the list.

 Surratt Beauty Noir Lash Tint
Who remembers the original Helena Rubenstein Long Lash mascara with the metal wand and beautiful gold tube? (I’m going WAY back—like officially vintage way back.) That’s the first thing I thought of when I saw this gorgeous mascara, and the alluring iridescent packaging instantly made me want to make it mine. (I don’t think I can resist any longer.)

Victoria Beckham Beauty Future Lash Mascara
I’m obsessed with post-Posh Victoria Beckham (and her husband), and I bought several pieces from her first makeup collaboration with Estée Lauder. I have yet to try anything from her solo line, but this mascara has my name on it. I love a tube mascara (the kind that coats your lashes and stays put until you wet your lashes and gently rub to remove it) because of the zero-smudge and flake factor, which I only now realized seems like a smart solution for steamy mask situations.

Kosas The Big Clean Mascara
I was first in line to try this mascara when it launched—but the formula recently underwent a renovation to give it more staying power. It promises the same fluffy lashes as its predecessor thanks to the firm, flexible bristles and curved design—and it still has all the lash-loving ingredients that you want with none of the “nasty” ingredients you don’t.

What’s a girl to do???